The butterfly effect or why climate change has a global impact even if it is local

This year, the Sindh region of Pakistan, the world’s fourth largest cotton producer with a production of 2,308 tonnes, has experienced one of the most difficult droughts in decades. Although this seems relatively isolated, it has a major impact on the global textile industry as it accounts for 6% of global cotton production. Thus, we can expect an increase in the price of textiles even in Romania, although we do not even know about the drought in Pakistan.

Cotton is the most important textile plant and provides over 70-75% of the world’s vegetable fiber production. After the cotton fibers have developed enough, they are harvested, turned into threads, which are then assembled in the form of fabric. The global textile industry is extremely dependent on cotton production. This in turn requires favorable weather conditions to be cultivated and extremely large amounts of water to be able to be transformed into the final product. For the manufacture of a single new cotton T-shirt, 2,700 liters of water are consumed, to which is added the energy consumed for transport and marketing. In this context, any drought or falling water levels can seriously affect cotton production. 

We should not expect a localized impact in Pakistan alone. The state of Texas (USA), which produces 43% of American cotton, has recently been hit by extreme weather events such as Hurricane Harvey in 2017 or the extreme winter of early 2021, which coupled with the lack of spring rainfall has led to a regional drought that largely compromised cotton crops.

India in turn is the second-largest producer of cotton in the world. 6,423 thousand metric tons of cotton are produced here every year. The reason for such a huge production is the climate which is most favorable in the northern part of the country. 

However, production in India is not exempt from the risks of climate change either. Thus extreme weather phenomena such as Cyclone Tauktae that hit India hard this year (with its floods affecting states Kerala, Karnataka, Tamil Nadu, Gujarat, Maharashtra and Goa) have a direct impact on cotton production, as it mainly happens in the areas of Maharashtra, Gujarat and Madhya.

These data show that global cotton production is exposed to climate fluctuations. Given the fact that the latest IPCC report indicates a possible increase in global temperatures by 1.8 to 4.0ºC and an increase in the intensity and periodicity of extreme weather events by 2100, it is not very difficult to imagine that cotton crops will be affected more and more often.

Why would it matter?

Being the main textile plant, the reduction of the cotton crop means an increase in the price of cotton-based textiles. So, according to the head of the National Retail Federation, Jack Kleinhenz, the price of a cotton T-shirt has increased on average from $ 1.50 to $ 2 during 2021. 

However, the increase does not come from higher production costs, but from the increase in price for raw material as shown in the price chart for US Cotton for the period Nov 2020 – Oct 2021.

Source: Capital.ro

Cotton production is not the only problem. Fast fashion – the constant emergence of new styles at very low prices – has led to a substantial increase in the amount of clothes with a relatively short lifespan. Thus, from the purchase of an item of clothing to its disposal, sometimes no more than a year passes. The way people dispose of clothes they no longer wear has also changed: they are no longer donated, but thrown directly in the trash.

Since 1996 the volume of clothes purchased on average of one person in the EU has increased by 40%. This was due to falling prices, which led to a reduction in the shelf life of clothing. Thus, Europeans consume almost 26 kg of textiles and throw away about 11 kg of textiles each year. Most of them, about 87%, are incinerated or dumped in landfills.

What can we do?

Globally, less than 1% of clothes are recycled as clothing, partly due to inadequate technology. The new EU strategy aims to find solutions to the phenomenon of fast fashion and to provide guidance for achieving high levels of separate collection of textile waste.

Under the Waste Directive approved by the European Parliament in 2018, EU countries will be required to introduce separate collection of textile waste by 2025. The Commission’s new strategy also contains measures that support production processes and circular materials, contribute to reducing hazardous chemicals and help consumers choose sustainable textiles.

The Union has an EU Eco-label, which manufacturers who meet the eco-criteria can apply to their products, which is a guarantee for the limited use of hazardous substances and low water and air pollution. The EU has also introduced a number of measures to mitigate the environmental impact of textile waste. Horizon 2020 funds RESYNTEX, a project that uses chemical recycling and should provide a business model for the future of the textile industry.

Regional events – global impact

Although the economy seems national, it is extremely connected to the flow of global goods. In this respect, the global economic circuits are exceptionally exposed to extreme weather phenomena that can affect the regions responsible for the production of raw materials. In the case of the textile industry, the high demand dictated by fast fashion coupled with the lower production, due to the reduced harvest, will mean a smaller supply in the future.

Cotton and the textile industry, in this context, are just one example of the effects that extreme weather events or climate change may have on global trade chains. Because the world economy is so interconnected, we can no longer talk about strictly local resilience to climate change. 

In a globalized economy, the “butterfly effect” (a phrase first used by mathematician and meteorologist Edward Lorenz) may exist. Dependence on a supplier, a country, an area or a supply route has effects on the markets. Therefore, we should act locally, coordinating our efforts for global impact. At the same time, we need to increase resilience by reducing consumption and keeping goods in the economic circuit for as long as possible.

This is a translated article from our Content Partners InfoClima. The original article is written by Alexandru Tătaru and can be found, in Romanian, here.

Share :

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Agenda FEL Energy Trilemma Workshop

13:30 – 14:00

Welcome coffee & networking

An informal opportunity for participants to meet and greet each other over coffee before the session begins.

14:00 – 15:00

Keynote speakers

Olivian Savin – Manager Communication & Marketing FEL Romania
Ștefan Gheorghe – Executive Director CNR-CME
Andrei Gurin – Sustainable Finance Unit, Team Leader – Taxonomy and Reporting, European Commission
Ana Nedea – Director of Strategy & Business Development, SIMTEL Team

15:00 – 15:20

Coffee break

15:20 – 16:30

Energy Trilemma Workshop

Olivian Savin – Manager Communication & Marketing FEL Romania

16:30 – 18:00

Networking wine tasting offered by Simtel Team

CEE Climate Connect Agenda

Date: October 17, 2024

Location: Representation of the European Commission in Romania, Lascăr 31 Business Center

Co-organized with the Representation of the European Commission in Romania and the EU Climate Pact, this Climate Change Summit side event is a speed networking session aimed at professionals and key stakeholders in Central and Eastern Europe. It offers a chance to quickly connect with influential people, build new relationships, and explore potential collaborations. The goal is to help participants make valuable connections that can support their work and initiatives in the region.

09:30 – 10:00

Welcome Coffee

An informal opportunity for participants to meet and greet each other over coffee before the session begins.

10:00 – 10:15

Welcome Remarks

Roxana Cojocaru, Executive Director, Social Innovation Solutions
Mara Roman, Deputy Head, Representation of the European Commission in Romania
Ana-Maria Pălăduș, Vice President, REPER21, National Coordinator for the EU Climate Pact in Romania

10:15 – 10:45

Participant Introductions

In this session, each participant will have the opportunity to introduce themselves briefly, sharing their role, the organization they represent, and their key areas of focus related to climate action and sustainability. This session is designed to give attendees a better understanding of who is present and to start identifying potential points of collaboration.

10:45 – 12:00

Facilitated Networking Activities

This interactive segment will guide participants through structured networking exercises, encouraging meaningful exchanges and collaboration opportunities. Activities will include:

  • Speed Networking: A fast-paced series of short, one-on-one conversations where participants can quickly introduce themselves and discuss mutual interests.
  • Group Discussions: Participants will be divided into small groups based on shared topics of interest (such as energy, agriculture, or urban sustainability) to explore ideas and possible synergies.
  • Collaboration Mapping: Using a visual tool, participants will highlight potential collaborations within the group, allowing them to identify common goals and resources that can be shared for future projects.

These activities are designed to help attendees make impactful connections in a short amount of time and foster potential long-term partnerships.

12:00 – 12:30

Lunch

A relaxed networking lunch where participants can continue their conversations and deepen connections made during the morning sessions.

ESG Leaders Forum Agenda

09:00 - 10:00

Registration and Welcome Coffee

10:00 - 10:15

Introduction and Welcome Address

Philippe Thibaud

Deputy CEO, BRD - Groupe Societe Generale

Philippe Gabulon

CEO, Societe Generale Global Solution Centre in Romania and Deputy CEO for SG GSC in India

Ciprian Stanescu

President Social innovation Solutions

Mihaela Frăsineanu

State Counselor, Prime Minister's Chancellery

10:15 - 10:45

Panel 1: Legislation

Codruț Nicolau

Founder, Sustain Future

Elena Cargnello

Member of the Board of Directors | Cogenio

Mihaela Frăsineanu

State Counselor, Prime Minister's Chancellery

10:45 - 11:15

Panel 2: Sustainable Finance & Investment

Aleksandra Palinska

Executive Director at Eurosif

Andrei Gurin

Sustainable Finance Unit, Team Leader – Taxonomy and Reporting, European Commission

Iuliana Tiba

Director Social Environment and Positive Financing Division BRD Groupe Société Générale

11:15 - 11:45

Panel 3: ESG Measurement and Reporting

Alexander Stevens

CEO, Greenomy

Fenya Sourla

Co-founder, COO & ESG Expert at Dataphoria

Kaisa Karjalainen

Director of the Mission Zero Academy (MiZA)

11:45 - 12.30

Panel 4: Examples of Good Practice in Business

Tiberiu Dănețiu

Corporate Affairs and Media Retail Director, Auchan Romania

Ioana Botezatu

Head of CSR, Societe Generale Global Solution Centre (SG GSC) India and Romania

Raluca Mocanu

Sustainability Leader, IKEA România

Boualem Saidi

Senior Bayer Representative for the Country Group and Managing Director of Bayer SRL Romania

12:30 - 13.00

Coffee Break

13.00 - 14.00

Breakout Sessions (3 simultaneous topics)

Room 1: Legislation
Room 2: How to make Sustainable Financing work (workshop led by Theresa Spandel, on implementation of the CSRD)
Room 3: ESG Measurement and Reporting in Practice (session led by Alexander Stevens)

14.00 - 15.00

Networking Lunch

Complete the form to download the report
To consume less energy
please turn off the lights!